Negotiation

Open-Ended Questions in Negotiation: What They Actually Reveal

November 10, 2026

A supplier asks for an eight percent price increase. The buyer has prepared the cost model and can challenge every figure. Yet after ten minutes, both sides are repeating their positions. The buyer has supplied arguments without learning what would actually make the supplier move.

An open-ended question can change the conversation. Rather than asking whether the supplier will accept three percent, the buyer might ask which costs have changed since the previous agreement and how those changes affect the requested increase. The answer could point to energy, production capacity or delivery patterns. None of those disclosures guarantees a concession. They do, however, give the buyer something specific to test.

What the experiments found

In a 2026 study, Matteo Di Stasi, Alison Wood Brooks and Jordi Quoidbach analysed 61,057 conversational turns from 309 two-person integrative negotiations. Open-ended questions accounted for only eight percent of turns, appearing roughly once every four minutes. Those who asked more tended to achieve better personal outcomes. Closed questions and statements did not show the same reliable association.

The researchers also tested the advice experimentally. In a study of 1,452 participants, negotiators instructed to use open-ended questions achieved higher personal gains than those instructed to ask closed questions or make statements. In another experiment involving 372 participants, preparing open-ended questions before negotiating outperformed preparing statements. The apparent mechanism was better information gathering and more opportunities for value creation.

The setting is important. These were integrative negotiations with several possible trade-offs. The findings cannot establish that open questions always win discounts in a purely distributive price negotiation, or that suppliers will disclose confidential cost data on request.

Questions that reveal negotiable variables

Imagine a maintenance quotation that includes an expensive on-call package. “Can you take ten percent off?” invites a yes or no. “Which service levels and response times are included in this charge?” may uncover support that the plant does not need, or a risk the buyer has underestimated. The conversation can then move from the headline price to what is being purchased.

If a supplier says that a delivery date is impossible, asking what limits its production schedule can distinguish a factory bottleneck from a transport issue. That matters because the buyer may be able to change batch sizes or accept partial deliveries. A refusal that first looked absolute may contain several workable options.

An open question is not a substitute for commercial scrutiny. “Walk me through how you calculated the adjustment” requests an explanation that can be checked. A relevant follow-up should respond to what the supplier actually said. That is the connection to active listening in negotiation: without listening closely, even a clever question produces little useful information.

Use closed questions to secure the result

Exploration has an endpoint. Once the buyer understands the constraints, a proposal and a decision must follow. Closed questions are valuable when confirming the agreement: “Does the revised unit price include freight?” or “Is this commitment valid for twelve months?” They turn an interesting discussion into verifiable terms.

Questions can also work against the buyer. Repeated “why” questions can sound accusatory, and an overly broad invitation may trigger a rehearsed sales pitch. Asking about every alternative after disclosing an urgent need can hand the supplier unnecessary leverage. Preparation therefore starts by identifying two or three uncertainties worth resolving, not collecting a long list of impressive phrases.

A useful spoken exercise is to rehearse the first minutes of a difficult supplier call. The counterpart resists the first question, then gives a partial answer. The buyer must follow that answer, test an assumption and formulate a conditional proposal. Recognition on paper is easy; choosing the next question under resistance is the part that needs practice.

The same approach helps when renegotiating a supplier quotation, where identifying the assumptions behind an offer is often more productive than demanding an arbitrary discount.

Put the technique into practice.

Read the idea, practise it in a spoken supplier conversation, and review feedback on your decisions.